To ascertain, observe which change between All of us Republican presidential optimistic Rick Santorum, and you can a unique Hampshire scholar. Let me reveal a change supply this new gist:

Santorum: I am merely positing some things you will want to think of. Anytime everyone has a straight to feel happier – so if you’re unsatisfied unless you’re partnered in order to four most other anyone is that Ok?

In reality, it seem to argue, that is on ft the the principle one heterosexuals implicitly enact in their own personal marriage preparations

Student: [The audience is these are] the proper for a couple of guys to obtain the same rights since the a person and you may a female.

That it change try interesting. Let’s understand why. His logic-which wide variety so you’re able to an excellent reductio advertisement absurdum-shall be spelled in the next method:

(1) Homosexual marriage supporters (such as those on audience in the a lot more than replace) keep that people deserve marry whomsoever they wanna, via common concur, in pursuit of their unique happiness. In the interest of fair treatment, after that, gay someone should be able to wed whomsoever they wish to, thru mutual agree, in search of their particular joy, too.

(2) But when you endorse you to definitely idea, Santorum rebuts, you are immediately committed to the position you to polygamy is ok. The reason being a person who would like to get married one or two, or three, or four, or five anybody, in the interest of their private delight, should also be entitled to do it – towards the “marriage-in-pursuit-of-happiness” principle more than – for as long as every person consents towards package. (more…)